// Copyright 2015-2019 Parity Technologies (UK) Ltd. // This file is part of Parity Ethereum. // Parity Ethereum is free software: you can redistribute it and/or modify // it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by // the Free Software Foundation, either version 3 of the License, or // (at your option) any later version. // Parity Ethereum is distributed in the hope that it will be useful, // but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of // MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the // GNU General Public License for more details. // You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License // along with Parity Ethereum. If not, see . //! Implementation of the Clique PoA Engine. //! //! File structure: //! - mod.rs -> Provides the engine API implementation, with additional block state tracking //! - block_state.rs -> Records the Clique state for given block. //! - params.rs -> Contains the parameters for the Clique engine. //! - step_service.rs -> An event loop to trigger sealing. //! - util.rs -> Various standalone utility functions. //! - tests.rs -> Consensus tests as defined in EIP-225. /// How syncing works: /// /// 1. Client will call: /// - `Clique::verify_block_basic()` /// - `Clique::verify_block_unordered()` /// - `Clique::verify_block_family()` /// 2. Using `Clique::state()` we try and retrieve the parent state. If this isn't found /// we need to back-fill it from the last known checkpoint. /// 3. Once we have a good state, we can record it using `CliqueBlockState::apply()`. /// How sealing works: /// /// 1. Set a signer using `Engine::set_signer()`. If a miner account was set up through /// a config file or CLI flag `MinerService::set_author()` will eventually set the signer /// 2. We check that the engine is ready for sealing through `Clique::sealing_state()` /// Note: This is always `SealingState::Ready` for Clique /// 3. Calling `Clique::new()` will spawn a `StepService` thread. This thread will call `Engine::step()` /// periodically. Internally, the Clique `step()` function calls `Client::update_sealing()`, which is /// what makes and seals a block. /// 4. `Clique::generate_seal()` will then be called by `miner`. This will return a `Seal` which /// is either a `Seal::None` or `Seal:Regular`. The following shows how a `Seal` variant is chosen: /// a. We return `Seal::None` if no signer is available or the signer is not authorized. /// b. If period == 0 and block has transactions, we return `Seal::Regular`, otherwise return `Seal::None`. /// c. If we're `INTURN`, wait for at least `period` since last block before trying to seal. /// d. If we're not `INTURN`, we wait for a random amount of time using the algorithm specified /// in EIP-225 before trying to seal again. /// 5. Miner will create new block, in process it will call several engine methods to do following: /// a. `Clique::open_block_header_timestamp()` must set timestamp correctly. /// b. `Clique::populate_from_parent()` must set difficulty to correct value. /// Note: `Clique::populate_from_parent()` is used in both the syncing and sealing code paths. /// 6. We call `Clique::on_seal_block()` which will allow us to modify the block header during seal generation. /// 7. Finally, `Clique::verify_local_seal()` is called. After this, the syncing code path will be followed /// in order to import the new block. use std::cmp; use std::collections::HashMap; use std::collections::VecDeque; use std::sync::{Arc, Weak}; use std::thread; use std::time; use std::time::{Instant, Duration, SystemTime, UNIX_EPOCH}; use block::ExecutedBlock; use client::{BlockId, EngineClient}; use engines::clique::util::{extract_signers, recover_creator}; use engines::{Engine, EngineError, Seal, SealingState}; use error::{BlockError, Error}; use ethereum_types::{Address, H64, H160, H256, U256}; use ethkey::Signature; use hash::KECCAK_EMPTY_LIST_RLP; use itertools::Itertools; use lru_cache::LruCache; use machine::{Call, Machine}; use parking_lot::RwLock; use rand::Rng; use super::signer::EngineSigner; use unexpected::{Mismatch, OutOfBounds}; use time_utils::CheckedSystemTime; use types::BlockNumber; use types::header::{ExtendedHeader, Header}; use self::block_state::CliqueBlockState; use self::params::CliqueParams; mod params; mod block_state; mod util; // TODO(niklasad1): extract tester types into a separate mod to be shared in the code base #[cfg(test)] mod tests; // Protocol constants /// Fixed number of extra-data prefix bytes reserved for signer vanity pub const VANITY_LENGTH: usize = 32; /// Fixed number of extra-data suffix bytes reserved for signer signature pub const SIGNATURE_LENGTH: usize = 65; /// Address length of signer pub const ADDRESS_LENGTH: usize = 20; /// Nonce value for DROP vote pub const NONCE_DROP_VOTE: H64 = H64([0; 8]); /// Nonce value for AUTH vote pub const NONCE_AUTH_VOTE: H64 = H64([0xff; 8]); /// Difficulty for INTURN block pub const DIFF_INTURN: U256 = U256([2, 0, 0, 0]); /// Difficulty for NOTURN block pub const DIFF_NOTURN: U256 = U256([1, 0, 0, 0]); /// Default empty author field value pub const NULL_AUTHOR: Address = H160([0x00; 20]); /// Default empty nonce value pub const NULL_NONCE: H64 = NONCE_DROP_VOTE; /// Default value for mixhash pub const NULL_MIXHASH: H256 = H256([0; 32]); /// Default value for uncles hash pub const NULL_UNCLES_HASH: H256 = KECCAK_EMPTY_LIST_RLP; /// Default noturn block wiggle factor defined in spec. pub const SIGNING_DELAY_NOTURN_MS: u64 = 500; /// How many CliqueBlockState to cache in the memory. pub const STATE_CACHE_NUM: usize = 128; /// Vote to add or remove the beneficiary #[derive(Copy, Clone, Debug, PartialEq, PartialOrd)] pub enum VoteType { Add, Remove, } impl VoteType { /// Try to construct a `Vote` from a nonce pub fn from_nonce(nonce: H64) -> Result { if nonce == NONCE_AUTH_VOTE { Ok(VoteType::Add) } else if nonce == NONCE_DROP_VOTE { Ok(VoteType::Remove) } else { Err(EngineError::CliqueInvalidNonce(nonce))? } } /// Get the rlp encoding of the vote pub fn as_rlp(&self) -> Vec> { match self { VoteType::Add => vec![rlp::encode(&NULL_MIXHASH), rlp::encode(&NONCE_AUTH_VOTE)], VoteType::Remove => vec![rlp::encode(&NULL_MIXHASH), rlp::encode(&NONCE_DROP_VOTE)], } } } /// Clique Engine implementation // block_state_by_hash -> block state indexed by header hash. #[cfg(not(test))] pub struct Clique { epoch_length: u64, period: u64, machine: Machine, client: RwLock>>, block_state_by_hash: RwLock>, proposals: RwLock>, signer: RwLock>>, } #[cfg(test)] /// Test version of `CliqueEngine` to make all fields public pub struct Clique { pub epoch_length: u64, pub period: u64, pub machine: Machine, pub client: RwLock>>, pub block_state_by_hash: RwLock>, pub proposals: RwLock>, pub signer: RwLock>>, } impl Clique { /// Initialize Clique engine from empty state. pub fn new(params: CliqueParams, machine: Machine) -> Result, Error> { /// Step Clique at most every 2 seconds const SEALING_FREQ: Duration = Duration::from_secs(2); let engine = Clique { epoch_length: params.epoch, period: params.period, client: Default::default(), block_state_by_hash: RwLock::new(LruCache::new(STATE_CACHE_NUM)), proposals: Default::default(), signer: Default::default(), machine, }; let engine = Arc::new(engine); let weak_eng = Arc::downgrade(&engine); thread::Builder::new().name("StepService".into()) .spawn(move || { loop { let next_step_at = Instant::now() + SEALING_FREQ; trace!(target: "miner", "StepService: triggering sealing"); if let Some(eng) = weak_eng.upgrade() { eng.step() } else { warn!(target: "shutdown", "StepService: engine is dropped; exiting."); break; } let now = Instant::now(); if now < next_step_at { thread::sleep(next_step_at - now); } } })?; Ok(engine) } #[cfg(test)] /// Initialize test variant of `CliqueEngine`, /// Note we need to `mock` the miner and it is introduced to test block verification to trigger new blocks /// to mainly test consensus edge cases pub fn with_test(epoch_length: u64, period: u64) -> Self { use spec::Spec; Self { epoch_length, period, client: Default::default(), block_state_by_hash: RwLock::new(LruCache::new(STATE_CACHE_NUM)), proposals: Default::default(), signer: Default::default(), machine: Spec::new_test_machine(), } } fn sign_header(&self, header: &Header) -> Result<(Signature, H256), Error> { match self.signer.read().as_ref() { None => { Err(EngineError::RequiresSigner)? } Some(signer) => { let digest = header.hash(); match signer.sign(digest) { Ok(sig) => Ok((sig, digest)), Err(e) => Err(EngineError::Custom(e.into()))?, } } } } /// Construct an new state from given checkpoint header. fn new_checkpoint_state(&self, header: &Header) -> Result { debug_assert_eq!(header.number() % self.epoch_length, 0); let mut state = CliqueBlockState::new( extract_signers(header)?); // TODO(niklasad1): refactor to perform this check in the `CliqueBlockState` constructor instead state.calc_next_timestamp(header.timestamp(), self.period)?; Ok(state) } fn state_no_backfill(&self, hash: &H256) -> Option { self.block_state_by_hash.write().get_mut(hash).cloned() } /// Get `CliqueBlockState` for given header, backfill from last checkpoint if needed. fn state(&self, header: &Header) -> Result { let mut block_state_by_hash = self.block_state_by_hash.write(); if let Some(state) = block_state_by_hash.get_mut(&header.hash()) { return Ok(state.clone()); } // If we are looking for an checkpoint block state, we can directly reconstruct it. if header.number() % self.epoch_length == 0 { let state = self.new_checkpoint_state(header)?; block_state_by_hash.insert(header.hash(), state.clone()); return Ok(state); } // BlockState is not found in memory, which means we need to reconstruct state from last checkpoint. match self.client.read().as_ref().and_then(|w| w.upgrade()) { None => { return Err(EngineError::RequiresClient)?; } Some(c) => { let last_checkpoint_number = header.number() - header.number() % self.epoch_length as u64; debug_assert_ne!(last_checkpoint_number, header.number()); // Catching up state, note that we don't really store block state for intermediary blocks, // for speed. let backfill_start = time::Instant::now(); trace!(target: "engine", "Back-filling block state. last_checkpoint_number: {}, target: {}({}).", last_checkpoint_number, header.number(), header.hash()); let mut chain = VecDeque::with_capacity((header.number() - last_checkpoint_number + 1) as usize); // Put ourselves in. chain.push_front(header.clone()); // populate chain to last checkpoint loop { let (last_parent_hash, last_num) = { let l = chain.front().expect("chain has at least one element; qed"); (*l.parent_hash(), l.number()) }; if last_num == last_checkpoint_number + 1 { break; } match c.block_header(BlockId::Hash(last_parent_hash)) { None => { return Err(BlockError::UnknownParent(last_parent_hash))?; } Some(next) => { chain.push_front(next.decode()?); } } } // Get the state for last checkpoint. let last_checkpoint_hash = *chain.front() .expect("chain has at least one element; qed") .parent_hash(); let last_checkpoint_header = match c.block_header(BlockId::Hash(last_checkpoint_hash)) { None => return Err(EngineError::CliqueMissingCheckpoint(last_checkpoint_hash))?, Some(header) => header.decode()?, }; let last_checkpoint_state = match block_state_by_hash.get_mut(&last_checkpoint_hash) { Some(state) => state.clone(), None => self.new_checkpoint_state(&last_checkpoint_header)?, }; block_state_by_hash.insert(last_checkpoint_header.hash(), last_checkpoint_state.clone()); // Backfill! let mut new_state = last_checkpoint_state.clone(); for item in &chain { new_state.apply(item, false)?; } new_state.calc_next_timestamp(header.timestamp(), self.period)?; block_state_by_hash.insert(header.hash(), new_state.clone()); let elapsed = backfill_start.elapsed(); trace!(target: "engine", "Back-filling succeed, took {} ms.", elapsed.as_millis()); Ok(new_state) } } } } impl Engine for Clique { fn name(&self) -> &str { "Clique" } fn machine(&self) -> &Machine { &self.machine } // Clique use same fields, nonce + mixHash fn seal_fields(&self, _header: &Header) -> usize { 2 } fn maximum_uncle_count(&self, _block: BlockNumber) -> usize { 0 } fn on_new_block( &self, _block: &mut ExecutedBlock, _epoch_begin: bool, ) -> Result<(), Error> { Ok(()) } // Clique has no block reward. fn on_close_block( &self, _block: &mut ExecutedBlock, _parent_header: &Header ) -> Result<(), Error> { Ok(()) } fn on_seal_block(&self, block: &mut ExecutedBlock) -> Result<(), Error> { trace!(target: "engine", "on_seal_block"); let header = &mut block.header; let state = self.state_no_backfill(header.parent_hash()) .ok_or_else(|| BlockError::UnknownParent(*header.parent_hash()))?; let is_checkpoint = header.number() % self.epoch_length == 0; header.set_author(NULL_AUTHOR); // Cast a random Vote if not checkpoint if !is_checkpoint { // TODO(niklasad1): this will always be false because `proposals` is never written to let votes = self.proposals.read().iter() .filter(|(address, vote_type)| state.is_valid_vote(*address, **vote_type)) .map(|(address, vote_type)| (*address, *vote_type)) .collect_vec(); if !votes.is_empty() { // Pick a random vote. let random_vote = rand::thread_rng().gen_range(0 as usize, votes.len()); let (beneficiary, vote_type) = votes[random_vote]; trace!(target: "engine", "Casting vote: beneficiary {}, type {:?} ", beneficiary, vote_type); header.set_author(beneficiary); header.set_seal(vote_type.as_rlp()); } } // Work on clique seal. let mut seal: Vec = Vec::with_capacity(VANITY_LENGTH + SIGNATURE_LENGTH); // At this point, extra_data should only contain miner vanity. if header.extra_data().len() != VANITY_LENGTH { Err(BlockError::ExtraDataOutOfBounds(OutOfBounds { min: Some(VANITY_LENGTH), max: Some(VANITY_LENGTH), found: header.extra_data().len() }))?; } // vanity { seal.extend_from_slice(&header.extra_data()[0..VANITY_LENGTH]); } // If we are building an checkpoint block, add all signers now. if is_checkpoint { seal.reserve(state.signers().len() * 20); state.signers().iter().foreach(|addr| { seal.extend_from_slice(&addr[..]); }); } header.set_extra_data(seal.clone()); // append signature onto extra_data let (sig, _msg) = self.sign_header(&header)?; seal.extend_from_slice(&sig[..]); header.set_extra_data(seal.clone()); header.compute_hash(); // locally sealed block don't go through valid_block_family(), so we have to record state here. let mut new_state = state.clone(); new_state.apply(&header, is_checkpoint)?; new_state.calc_next_timestamp(header.timestamp(), self.period)?; self.block_state_by_hash.write().insert(header.hash(), new_state); trace!(target: "engine", "on_seal_block: finished, final header: {:?}", header); Ok(()) } /// Clique doesn't require external work to seal, so we always return true here. fn sealing_state(&self) -> SealingState { SealingState::Ready } /// Returns if we are ready to seal, the real sealing (signing extra_data) is actually done in `on_seal_block()`. fn generate_seal(&self, block: &ExecutedBlock, parent: &Header) -> Seal { trace!(target: "engine", "tried to generate_seal"); let null_seal = util::null_seal(); if block.header.number() == 0 { trace!(target: "engine", "attempted to seal genesis block"); return Seal::None; } // if sealing period is 0, and not an checkpoint block, refuse to seal if self.period == 0 { if block.transactions.is_empty() && block.header.number() % self.epoch_length != 0 { return Seal::None; } return Seal::Regular(null_seal); } // Check we actually have authority to seal. if let Some(author) = self.signer.read().as_ref().map(|x| x.address()) { // ensure the voting state exists match self.state(&parent) { Err(e) => { warn!(target: "engine", "generate_seal: can't get parent state(number: {}, hash: {}): {} ", parent.number(), parent.hash(), e); return Seal::None; } Ok(state) => { // Are we authorized to seal? if !state.is_authorized(&author) { trace!(target: "engine", "generate_seal: Not authorized to sign right now."); // wait for one third of period to try again. thread::sleep(Duration::from_secs(self.period / 3 + 1)); return Seal::None; } let inturn = state.is_inturn(block.header.number(), &author); let now = SystemTime::now(); let limit = match inturn { true => state.next_timestamp_inturn.unwrap_or(now), false => state.next_timestamp_noturn.unwrap_or(now), }; // Wait for the right moment. if now < limit { trace!(target: "engine", "generate_seal: sleeping to sign: inturn: {}, now: {:?}, to: {:?}.", inturn, now, limit); match limit.duration_since(SystemTime::now()) { Ok(duration) => { thread::sleep(duration); }, Err(e) => { warn!(target:"engine", "generate_seal: unable to sleep, err: {}", e); return Seal::None; } } } trace!(target: "engine", "generate_seal: seal ready for block {}, txs: {}.", block.header.number(), block.transactions.len()); return Seal::Regular(null_seal); } } } Seal::None } fn verify_local_seal(&self, _header: &Header) -> Result<(), Error> { Ok(()) } fn verify_block_basic(&self, header: &Header) -> Result<(), Error> { // Largely same as https://github.com/ethereum/go-ethereum/blob/master/consensus/clique/clique.go#L275 // Ignore genesis block. if header.number() == 0 { return Ok(()); } // Don't waste time checking blocks from the future { let limit = CheckedSystemTime::checked_add(SystemTime::now(), Duration::from_secs(self.period)) .ok_or(BlockError::TimestampOverflow)?; // This should succeed under the contraints that the system clock works let limit_as_dur = limit.duration_since(UNIX_EPOCH).map_err(|e| { Box::new(format!("Converting SystemTime to Duration failed: {}", e)) })?; let hdr = Duration::from_secs(header.timestamp()); if hdr > limit_as_dur { let found = CheckedSystemTime::checked_add(UNIX_EPOCH, hdr).ok_or(BlockError::TimestampOverflow)?; Err(BlockError::TemporarilyInvalid(OutOfBounds { min: None, max: Some(limit), found, }.into()))? } } let is_checkpoint = header.number() % self.epoch_length == 0; if is_checkpoint && *header.author() != NULL_AUTHOR { return Err(EngineError::CliqueWrongAuthorCheckpoint(Mismatch { expected: H160::zero(), found: *header.author(), }))?; } let seal_fields = header.decode_seal::>()?; if seal_fields.len() != 2 { Err(BlockError::InvalidSealArity(Mismatch { expected: 2, found: seal_fields.len(), }))? } let mixhash = H256::from_slice(seal_fields[0]); let nonce = H64::from_slice(seal_fields[1]); // Nonce must be 0x00..0 or 0xff..f if nonce != NONCE_DROP_VOTE && nonce != NONCE_AUTH_VOTE { Err(EngineError::CliqueInvalidNonce(nonce))?; } if is_checkpoint && nonce != NULL_NONCE { Err(EngineError::CliqueInvalidNonce(nonce))?; } // Ensure that the mix digest is zero as Clique don't have fork protection currently if mixhash != NULL_MIXHASH { Err(BlockError::MismatchedH256SealElement(Mismatch { expected: NULL_MIXHASH, found: mixhash, }))? } let extra_data_len = header.extra_data().len(); if extra_data_len < VANITY_LENGTH { Err(EngineError::CliqueMissingVanity)? } if extra_data_len < VANITY_LENGTH + SIGNATURE_LENGTH { Err(EngineError::CliqueMissingSignature)? } let signers = extra_data_len - (VANITY_LENGTH + SIGNATURE_LENGTH); // Checkpoint blocks must at least contain one signer if is_checkpoint && signers == 0 { Err(EngineError::CliqueCheckpointNoSigner)? } // Addresses must be be divisable by 20 if is_checkpoint && signers % ADDRESS_LENGTH != 0 { Err(EngineError::CliqueCheckpointInvalidSigners(signers))? } // Ensure that the block doesn't contain any uncles which are meaningless in PoA if *header.uncles_hash() != NULL_UNCLES_HASH { Err(BlockError::InvalidUnclesHash(Mismatch { expected: NULL_UNCLES_HASH, found: *header.uncles_hash(), }))? } // Ensure that the block's difficulty is meaningful (may not be correct at this point) if *header.difficulty() != DIFF_INTURN && *header.difficulty() != DIFF_NOTURN { Err(BlockError::DifficultyOutOfBounds(OutOfBounds { min: Some(DIFF_NOTURN), max: Some(DIFF_INTURN), found: *header.difficulty(), }))? } // All basic checks passed, continue to next phase Ok(()) } fn verify_block_unordered(&self, _header: &Header) -> Result<(), Error> { // Nothing to check here. Ok(()) } /// Verify block family by looking up parent state (backfill if needed), then try to apply current header. /// see https://github.com/ethereum/go-ethereum/blob/master/consensus/clique/clique.go#L338 fn verify_block_family(&self, header: &Header, parent: &Header) -> Result<(), Error> { // Ignore genesis block. if header.number() == 0 { return Ok(()); } // parent sanity check if parent.hash() != *header.parent_hash() || header.number() != parent.number() + 1 { Err(BlockError::UnknownParent(parent.hash()))? } // Ensure that the block's timestamp isn't too close to it's parent let limit = parent.timestamp().saturating_add(self.period); if limit > header.timestamp() { let max = CheckedSystemTime::checked_add(UNIX_EPOCH, Duration::from_secs(header.timestamp())); let found = CheckedSystemTime::checked_add(UNIX_EPOCH, Duration::from_secs(limit)) .ok_or(BlockError::TimestampOverflow)?; Err(BlockError::InvalidTimestamp(OutOfBounds { min: None, max, found, }.into()))? } // Retrieve the parent state let parent_state = self.state(&parent)?; // Try to apply current state, apply() will further check signer and recent signer. let mut new_state = parent_state.clone(); new_state.apply(header, header.number() % self.epoch_length == 0)?; new_state.calc_next_timestamp(header.timestamp(), self.period)?; self.block_state_by_hash.write().insert(header.hash(), new_state); Ok(()) } fn genesis_epoch_data(&self, header: &Header, _call: &Call) -> Result, String> { let mut state = self.new_checkpoint_state(header).expect("Unable to parse genesis data."); state.calc_next_timestamp(header.timestamp(), self.period).map_err(|e| format!("{}", e))?; self.block_state_by_hash.write().insert(header.hash(), state); // no proof. Ok(Vec::new()) } // Our task here is to set difficulty fn populate_from_parent(&self, header: &mut Header, parent: &Header) { // TODO(https://github.com/paritytech/parity-ethereum/issues/10410): this is a horrible hack, // it is due to the fact that enact and miner both use OpenBlock::new() which will both call // this function. more refactoring is definitely needed. if header.extra_data().len() < VANITY_LENGTH + SIGNATURE_LENGTH { trace!(target: "engine", "populate_from_parent in sealing"); // It's unclear how to prevent creating new blocks unless we are authorized, the best way (and geth does this too) // it's just to ignore setting a correct difficulty here, we will check authorization in next step in generate_seal anyway. if let Some(signer) = self.signer.read().as_ref() { let state = match self.state(&parent) { Err(e) => { trace!(target: "engine", "populate_from_parent: Unable to find parent state: {}, ignored.", e); return; } Ok(state) => state, }; if state.is_authorized(&signer.address()) { if state.is_inturn(header.number(), &signer.address()) { header.set_difficulty(DIFF_INTURN); } else { header.set_difficulty(DIFF_NOTURN); } } let zero_padding_len = VANITY_LENGTH.saturating_sub(header.extra_data().len()); if zero_padding_len > 0 { let mut resized_extra_data = header.extra_data().clone(); resized_extra_data.resize(VANITY_LENGTH, 0); header.set_extra_data(resized_extra_data); } } else { trace!(target: "engine", "populate_from_parent: no signer registered"); } } } fn set_signer(&self, signer: Box) { trace!(target: "engine", "set_signer: {}", signer.address()); *self.signer.write() = Some(signer); } fn register_client(&self, client: Weak) { *self.client.write() = Some(client.clone()); } fn step(&self) { if self.signer.read().is_some() { if let Some(ref weak) = *self.client.read() { if let Some(c) = weak.upgrade() { c.update_sealing(); } } } } /// Clique timestamp is set to parent + period , or current time which ever is higher. fn open_block_header_timestamp(&self, parent_timestamp: u64) -> u64 { let now = time::SystemTime::now().duration_since(time::UNIX_EPOCH).unwrap_or_default(); cmp::max(now.as_secs() as u64, parent_timestamp.saturating_add(self.period)) } fn is_timestamp_valid(&self, header_timestamp: u64, parent_timestamp: u64) -> bool { header_timestamp >= parent_timestamp.saturating_add(self.period) } fn fork_choice(&self, new: &ExtendedHeader, current: &ExtendedHeader) -> super::ForkChoice { super::total_difficulty_fork_choice(new, current) } // Clique uses the author field for voting, the real author is hidden in the `extra_data` field. // So when executing tx's (like in `enact()`) we want to use the executive author fn executive_author(&self, header: &Header) -> Result { recover_creator(header) } }